Ugh, that's awful! There are a lot of breeders that put that guy up on a pedestal but I think that he also did a lot of damage to the breed as a whole.
Is M still going to buy him? I'm just so so sorry about this whole situation. If you bred Sam and only kept her offspring that did NOT have white toenails..I imagine that it would still be possible to show up in future generations?
Also, what if Sam had not had white toenails and her siblings had (and were culled/not bred) - would she still be a carrier?
Hopefully these questions aren't too painful for you right now. I'm just very curious as I've had white toenails pop up in one litter and was concerned about using the siblings that didn't have them.
Hey guys, Kelly here.
I have raised Tans since the early-mid 90s and have produced hundreds of Tans in that time. I have had two white toenails. One was on a blue and out of non-Joe Kim rabbits. White or light toenails happen fairly commonly on all dilutes of all breeds. I have only had one black with a white toenail. It was promptly terminally culled. That rabbit was out of two non-Joe Kim rabbits from one breeder. I will absolutely not bring the breeder's name into this discussion (I respect this person a lot and in general will not breeder bash), but I bought 11 rabbits from that breeder and had to cull all but 3 for white spots and/or white toenails either on the actual rabbits or the rabbits they produced. Ironically, the three rabbits from him/her I did not have issues with were of a pure Joe Kim background. The mother of the rabbit of Sarah's with the white toenail is from the same breeder that I had issues with. So I wouldn't blame poor Sinatra. Could it have been him? Sure. But there is no way to know for sure and in this situation it seems unlikely.
I think one thing we all need to remember is that Tans are not a finished product. Like ALL breeds, they are continually a work in progress. DQs and other not fun things will pop up, period. That will never change. It will get better over time as we continue to improve our gene pool through tough culling. It has already gotten much better than it was 10 years ago, let alone 20 years ago when I got my first Tan.
Joe Kim was instrumental in revolutionizing the breed. I know I sound biased, but I'm honestly not saying that as a friend of his. I'm saying that as someone who saw it happen. Yes, adding imports added some issues. But the pros clearly outweighed the cons. The Tans you have fallen in love with (the sleek, flashy showy rabbit) would not exist without Joe. Instead, we would likely still have cobby, Florida White typed Tans hobbling awkwardly down the show table. The worst Tans I see on a show table today are better than the best Tans I saw on a show table back when I first began. Tans rarely won Best in Show before Joe Kim, the ATRSC was much smaller and breed numbers at shows were low as well.
Also, you can't avoid imports. ALL Tans have import lines. ALL of them, even if they do not show in the pedigree. Tans are originally imports and the imports that came into this country again in the early 2000s have been successfully disseminated throughout the country. You cannot raise Tans without having import lines. I do not think white toenails are very common with imports at this point. It's mostly been culled out and my experience has been that those who have white toenails or spots pop up have the aforementioned breeder in common.
Are there problems that are more prevalent in Tans? Of course. But really, only butting teeth and split *****. And even those are not common problems. But it does happen. All breeds have their issues. Rex are prone to sore hocks. Dwarfs get butting teeth (not to mention the awful birth defects). I could go on and on.
Sorry if I seem defensive. I just don't want my name (in a public forum) associated with a problem that absolutely does not exist in my herd. Is my herd perfect? Definitely not. But this particular problem just isn't a problem I have.
- Kelly
Sarah, is she 6 months old yet? I found out at PaSRBA that they shouldn't actually jump until then, that you just do harness training with them. Oh, and they can run up and down the stairs in your house. Just not actual jumps (which doesn't make sense to me, but I'm a newb. lol).
Enter your email address to join: