LOL on the "eeny, meany"! The weights are low (they just turned 8 weeks old). We did learn to do the breeding math ourselves and not listen to what the 4-H leader said! If we would have had them closer to the 10 week mark, weight wouldn't even be an issue. Live and learn, which is why she's in 4-H.
The ones we picked weren't the heaviest. But they're almost exact replicas. After we got them narrowed down to 4 for each pen, we lined the "top 3" from each pen. And they look identical! And they are solid, nice depth, great hindquarters...just a good batch of rabbits, making the selection harder. We ended up tossing some back into the "sale" section due to being a tad lighter in coloring, to narrow it down more.
The 4-H leader also told me that trios sell better at the sale than all bucks. So I think we're going to do that route. She's picked 2 does and a buck to keep for her program, we have Twila and one of her does sold, and a buck (any buck, they just want a nice quality). The rest we can hopefully sell at the fair itself.
I just wasn't sure if we could go with the heaviest ones, because the difference between the lightest of the trio and the heaviest is right at 4 oz. And, honestly, even though they'r heavier I'm not a fan of the heaviest one's hindquarters.
Oh, and I also found out the Grand Champion pen last year was barely over 3 lbs. I just wish I know how Paul Kyle likes them...how many points he mentally adds for weight. *sigh*